What Makes a Good Rental Property?
If you’re considering investing in a rental property, one of the most important questions to ask is: what makes a good rental home? The right property doesn’t just attract tenants quickly, it helps you achieve reliable returns and makes future resale easier too. From our experience at A Flat In Town, here are the key ingredients we think make a property stand out.
1. Location, Location… Balance
Of course, location matters, but it’s not always about buying in the most premium areas. Desirable spots tend to have good transport links, local shops, and a sense of community. Central locations are always in demand, but don’t overlook the neighbourhoods next door to the most sought-after postcodes.
In Edinburgh, for example, Abbeyhill, Gorgie, and Dalry have fantastic pockets of more affordable one-bedroom flats that tenants love, without the higher purchase prices you’d pay in Stockbridge, Bruntsfield, or the New Town. The key is striking the right balance between purchase cost and rental return.
2. A “Wow” Factor
We love a property with at least one standout feature. It doesn’t have to be grand, it just has to give tenants something to fall in love with. This could be a bay window, a leafy view, a period cornice, or a bathroom finished with a touch of luxury. Outdoor space is always a winner, whether it’s a balcony, a private garden, or even a well-kept shared garden.
Sometimes it’s the practical extras that make the difference: clever storage, or a box room that works perfectly as a home office. A “wow” factor makes marketing easier and can pay off again when it comes time to sell.
3. Clean and Fresh
No matter the style, age, or location of the property, presentation is everything. A well-maintained, clean, and fresh home shows tenants that you care about being a good landlord – and in turn, you’re more likely to attract tenants who care about looking after the property too.
4. Practical and Functional
Great rental properties don’t just look good, they work well. The layout should make sense, rooms should be easily accessible, and kitchens and bathrooms should be well-equipped. Practical considerations matter: a ground or mid-floor flat can sometimes be more appealing than a top-floor one (fewer stairs, and fewer worries about potential roof issues).
At the end of the day, a property that functions smoothly appeals to a broader range of tenants, helping reduce void periods and stress for landlords.
5. Energy Efficiency and Compliance
More and more tenants are looking at running costs. Energy-efficient properties not only help tenants keep bills down, but they also make it easier for landlords to meet regulations. Features like double glazing, good insulation, and modern heating systems can make a big difference.
6. Flexibility for the Future
Think about who your property will appeal to long-term. A one-bedroom flat in a well-connected area might always attract young professionals, while a two-bedroom home with outdoor space could appeal to young families or sharers. The more versatile your property is, the more secure your rental prospects will be over time.
Final Thoughts
A good rental property is about striking the right balance: location, character, functionality, and presentation. Add in strong energy performance and broad appeal, and you’ve got a recipe for an investment that works for both you and your tenants.
At A Flat In Town, we see time and again that when landlords take care in choosing and maintaining the right property, everything else – from finding tenants to long-term returns – becomes much easier.
If you are looking at investing in a property, we are always happy to advise. Please do get in touch!


